Here's the situation from today. I'm sure I wasn't correct by the book but I don't feel I did the wrong thing.
Ethan was removed for a sub in the top of the third. In the top of the fourth, his team wants to make a pitching change so that their pitcher can be used in a couple of days. Ethan goes to the mound and starts warming up.
Now, the manager knew he could return a starter to the game but didn't know the sub had to have 6 and 1 before they could.
Ethan then, was an ineligible substitute. They pulled him off and I allowed them to return the original pitcher to the mound.
Like this post to subscribe to the topic.